I debated whether or not to even post this, but I'm curious about other people's perspective on this. My pastoral position in my church is important to me, so I'll be changing a few details to keep things sufficiently anonymous.
I'm an agnostic atheist. Truthfully, I don't know what lies beyond this life and there's no definitive way to tell at the moment. Given the evidence we do have, I choose to air on the side of atheism.
I live in a culturally conservative, somewhat rural area. The people are mostly great. Very friendly and outgoing, always trying to feed you or show you the arrowheads they dug up on their land. It's not a secret that Christian-based authoritarianism is sweeping the United States and has been for many years now, I don't think that's particularly controversial to say. Folks in my community aren't immune to the propaganda, and I noticed a real mean streak starting to form in the town a few years back.
At the time, I'd been out of a job for a few months already and was looking to go in a different career direction. I noticed that there was a very close-proximity job listing online for an adult ministry pastor.
I've been an avid reader of the Bible for years. Not in a religious way, more in the way one would enjoy Greek myths. I think it's a very intriguing text with plenty of philosophical food for thought. I also believe it to be a work of fiction. And yet, millions of people have based their lives on this text. It's become a part of them. Etched into every facet of their world. It is, in my opinion, a fool's errand to convert these people. You can, however, de-radicalize them. Thanks to my expansive Biblical knowledge and someone genuinely good conversation with my interviewer, I got the job!!
I saw a unique opportunity to pull people back from a cliff's edge. To promote kindness, tolerance, and empathy in the minds of people who were, frankly, a cult leader's dream flock. I didn't immediately come in and start "saving souls". In fact, I got a lot of push-back in the first six months or so because I wouldn't condemn whatever boogeyman of the day was keeping FOX News viewers up at night.
Instead, I told them that God is clever and knows the hearts of men. He knows that some will follow Him only for the riches waiting for them in the Kingdom of Heaven. The pot of gold at the end of the rainbow. Many will be lead astray by their pride and hardness of heart. I told them that God commands us to love our fellow man and leave the judgment to Him. After all, if we can't embody the kindness, mercy, and generosity of our Savior, how can we possibly expect to eat next to Him at His table?
A few people left, most stayed. I preached, yes, but I also got into the principles of Kant, Kierkegaard, and Stuart Mill through the lens of scripture. I explicitly went into Machiavellianism with one of my advanced scripture study classes, drawing parallels with Machiavelli's principles and the propaganda machine that seeks to weaponize their own faith. It really blew some minds! With a little refinement and editing, it's a lesson I now teach in my main sermons.
It's like I said before, these folks aren't bad. They don't have cruelty or bigotry coded into their DNA, it's something they've been taught and primed for. When you give them a better alternative, even if it's through their spirituality, most will be glad to embrace it.
I broke down crying the other day in front of my congregation. They thought I was overcome with the Spirit, but really, I was just proud of them. So many of them had done real change in their lives. Become better people. Closer to God, as I might say on the pulpit. Over these last few years my religious beliefs haven't changed, but my belief in the goodness of humans has been strengthened immensely.
Thanks for reading :)